How To Know If You Have A Valid Medical Malpractice Case?

An unexpected injury after medical treatment can raise difficult questions. A complication, unsuccessful treatment or poor outcome does not by itself establish medical malpractice. A potential Pennsylvania or New Jersey claim needs an individual review of the care, medical evidence and applicable law.

What must a medical malpractice claim show?

In general, a negligence claim requires a duty of care, a failure to meet the applicable standard of care, a causal connection between that failure and the patient’s harm, and resulting damages. An injury alone does not establish these elements. A federal court applying Pennsylvania law summarizes these requirements in Richardson v. United States, pages 19–20 (PDF).

A missed diagnosis, medication problem, surgical complication or lack of follow-up may warrant investigation. Whether it supports a claim depends on the facts and the governing law. Appropriate medical experts are often needed to assess the standard of care and causation; a concern about treatment is a starting point for review, not a finding of liability.

What records help with the review?

Keep the records you already have, including visit notes, discharge instructions, medication lists, test results and imaging reports. Write a timeline of treatment, symptoms and follow-up, and note how the injury affected daily life, work and expenses. A lawyer can help identify additional records and the expert review a potential case needs. You do not need to decide on your own whether the care was negligent before asking for a consultation.

Pennsylvania and New Jersey have different procedures

In Pennsylvania, Rule 1042.3 generally requires a certificate of merit with the complaint or within 60 days after filing when the action alleges a licensed professional departed from an acceptable professional standard. The rule provides different certification grounds and allows extensions for good cause. Counsel should assess which requirements apply.

In New Jersey, N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27 generally requires an affidavit from an appropriate licensed professional within 60 days after the defendant files an answer. The court may allow one additional period of up to 60 days for good cause. Medical-malpractice affidavits also have expert-qualification requirements. Exceptions and case-specific issues need legal review.

These are separate state procedures, not a general medical-review-board approval process. Their time periods are not the deadline for starting a lawsuit. Filing deadlines depend on the facts and applicable law, so seek advice promptly rather than waiting to collect every record.

Discuss your questions with Edelstein Law

Our Pennsylvania and New Jersey medical malpractice team can review the circumstances and discuss potential next steps. Call (215) 893-9311 or (856) 809-3150 to request a free consultation. An inquiry does not create an attorney-client relationship or protect a deadline.

Updated November 4, 2026. General information and attorney advertising, not individual legal or medical advice. No outcome is guaranteed.

Previous
Previous

Understanding Wrongful Death Legal Claims In Philadelphia

Next
Next

Removing The Stigma of Reporting A Sexual Assault From Your Childhood