Automobile Liability

What happens when you let a friend drive your vehicle and they get in a car crash?

If someone crashes your car after borrowing it, insurance coverage and legal responsibility are separate questions. This article focuses on Pennsylvania. Start with your policy and the Pennsylvania Insurance Department’s auto insurance resources; another state’s rules may differ.

Insurance coverage for a borrowed vehicle

Many personal auto policies cover a licensed occasional driver who has permission to use the car, often called permissive use. Coverage is not automatic. The vehicle’s policy may respond, and the borrower’s own policy may also apply. Coverage and the order of payment depend on the applicable policies, limits, exclusions and accident facts. Do not assume the borrower’s insurance automatically pays amounts above the owner’s limits.

Liability, vehicle damage and medical benefits

The Pennsylvania Auto Insurance Guide (PDF) explains these different coverages:

  • Liability coverage: Bodily injury and property damage liability cover damages to other people for which an insured person is legally responsible, subject to policy terms and limits. They do not repair your own car.

  • Damage to your car: Optional collision coverage generally pays for covered crash damage to your vehicle. Comprehensive coverage addresses other covered losses, such as theft. A deductible may apply to these claims; do not assume the same deductible applies to a liability claim.

  • Medical benefits: Pennsylvania first-party medical benefits can pay covered medical expenses regardless of fault. They have separate statutory priority and eligibility rules; they are not the same as bodily injury liability insurance.

An at-fault driver’s liability insurance may cover a claim, but payment is not guaranteed. Fault, available coverage, policy limits and other facts must be evaluated.

Permission, household drivers and exclusions

Tell your insurer about household members and people who regularly drive your car, and ask whether they must be listed. Living in the household does not by itself establish coverage. A driver who is not listed is not necessarily the same as a driver expressly excluded under the policy.

Read any driver exclusion and ask which coverages it affects. If a vehicle is taken without permission, coverage and liability require a fact-specific review. An uninsured borrower does not automatically require the owner’s insurer to pay, and lack of permission does not by itself resolve every coverage or negligence issue.

Owner liability in Pennsylvania

Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 1574, an owner or person controlling a vehicle must not permit an unauthorized or improperly licensed person to drive it on a highway. A person who violates that rule is jointly and severally liable with the driver for damages caused by the driver’s negligence.

A negligent entrustment claim (Pennsylvania court opinion, PDF) may arise when someone permits use of a vehicle knowing, or having reason to know, that the driver is likely to create an unreasonable risk, and the driver’s negligence causes harm. Lending a vehicle to an impaired or otherwise unsafe driver can raise this issue. Ownership alone does not answer the liability question.

After a crash involving a borrowed car

  • Attend to injuries and immediate safety, and document the accident and who had permission to drive.

  • Notify the relevant insurers promptly, review both policies and ask for a written coverage explanation.

  • Keep the declarations, driver exclusions, claim correspondence and evidence of loss. Seek legal advice about disputed coverage or responsibility.

If your car has been involved in a crash after you lent it to a friend, you may want to consider seeking legal advice from an auto injury lawyer. Call Edelstein Law Offices at (215) 893-9311 for a free consultation.

Previous
Previous

Slip and Fall in PA

Next
Next

How to Choose Auto Insurance